Why training groups stay silent and what to do about it
Przemek Blicharski5 min read
You ask the room and three people answer
You know the moment. Twenty people hear your question and the same three speak up as always. The rest look at their notes or their phones. It is easy to conclude that the group is passive or unprepared. Usually the opposite is true: people have a view, they just see no reason to risk saying it.
I have been running training courses since 2018, and as a psychologist I treat a silent room as behaviour with a cause. Change the cause and the behaviour changes.
Evaluation apprehension: the calculation every participant makes
Before raising a hand, a participant runs a split-second cost check. Will I look like someone who doesn't know? What will my manager two seats away think? Will colleagues remember that I asked something obvious? If the sum comes out negative, a sensible person stays quiet.
At in-company training this calculation is especially harsh, because the people in the room are the ones the participant will work with tomorrow and next year. Open courses with strangers warm up faster.
The Asch effect and pluralistic ignorance
In Solomon Asch's classic experiments from the 1950s, people compared the lengths of lines. When planted participants all gave the same wrong answer, real subjects went along with them in about a third of trials, even though they could see it was wrong. Group pressure works even where there is nothing to debate.
The second mechanism is pluralistic ignorance. Everyone in the room is unsure about something, but they see that nobody asks, so each assumes they are the only one struggling. Dale Miller and Cathy McFarland described this in 1987 using the example of students who do not ask questions in class.
The first answer spoken aloud sets the tone for the rest of the room. If the manager says “this works for us”, the group rarely says otherwise.
Psychological safety in a training room
In 1999 Amy Edmondson of Harvard used the term psychological safety for a team's belief that you can ask a question or admit a mistake without being punished. Google's Project Aristotle studied 180 of the company's own teams, and this kind of safety set the most effective teams apart more than anything else.
A trainer cannot build it in a day, because it depends on company culture. What you can do is lower the cost of speaking up in your own sessions. The simplest way is an answer that nobody can link to a specific person.
Six ways to use the first 15 minutes of a course
- Start with a question about participants' experience. “What are you bringing with you today?” has only good answers.
- Let people answer anonymously on their phones. Seeing the result on screen shows that others think the same, which makes it easier to talk out loud.
- Ask a scale question about knowledge at the start. Participants see they are not the only beginners, and you get a baseline for the end of the day.
- Collect questions all day and answer them before breaks. A question sent from a phone interrupts nobody and takes no courage.
- Comment on the group's result, never on a single answer. Saying “half of you named lack of time” opens a conversation without pointing fingers.
- Hold the first spoken discussion in pairs or threes. In a small group the cost of a mistake drops almost to zero.
Why a show of hands gives you the wrong picture
A show of hands measures courage and how the neighbours vote. When the room answers on phones, the result often looks different: more people admit they do not use something or disagree with it. That result is more useful to a trainer because it shows where the group really stands.
Mentlik grew out of this observation. Participants type a 6-digit code and answer with no name or email, and the screen shows the view of the whole room. I describe how to measure what stays with people after the course in Training evaluation survey.
Frequently asked questions
Why don't participants ask questions during training?
Because they judge that asking in front of their manager and colleagues costs more than staying silent. On top of that, everyone sees that others are not asking and assumes they are the only one who does not understand.
How do you engage training participants at the start of the day?
Start with an easy question about their experience, let them answer anonymously on their phones and comment on the group result rather than individual answers. Hold the first spoken discussion in small groups.
Does anonymous voting make sense in training?
Yes, when you want the view of the whole room. An anonymous answer collects the voice of people who, with a show of hands, would vote like their neighbours or not at all.
What is psychological safety?
It is a team's belief that you can ask a question or admit a mistake without being punished. Amy Edmondson described the concept in 1999.
See how the whole room answers
On the page for trainers you can vote in the demo and watch the result appear on screen live.
Try the demo
About the author
Przemek Blicharski
Psychologist and trainer, PBX Agency